The Cycle of
Market Emotions
You have probably heard of the investment cycle - where markets move
and investment options go up and down. But have you heard about the cycle
of our emotions?When
things are great we feel that nothing can stop us. And when things go bad
we look to take drastic action.
Because emotions can be such a
threat to our financial health it is important that we are aware of them.
This awareness can then protect us
from the negative consequences of impulsive and irrational reactions to
them.
As investors, we all start with
optimism. We commonly expect things to go our way, or, to be honest we
tend to expect a return for the risk of investing.
As our expectations are met, we
get excited about the possibility of even greater returns and the
excitement becomes thrilling as the returns exceed our expectations.
We are at the top of the cycle
when we experience euphoria. But it is at this point that we are at the
point of maximum financial risk.
When we believe everything that we
touch turns to gold, we fool ourselves into believing that we can beat the
market, that we cannot make mistakes, that excessive returns are common
place and that we can tolerate higher levels of risk.
This euphoria was experienced by
many investors in the recent property boom.
House prices were going through
the roof and many investors expected this trend to continue.
The second phase of the cycle
occurs when the market stops meeting our new lofty expectations and begins
to turn. At first, we anxiously watch the market for any signs of
direction. Our anxiety turns to denial and then quickly to fear as the
value of our investments decline. We start to act defensively and may
think about switching out of riskier assets to more defensive shares
on-other asset classes such as bonds.
In the third phase of the cycle,
the realities of a bear market come to the fore and we become desperate.
Many of us panic and withdraw from the market altogether - afraid of
further losses. Those of us who persevere become despondent and we wonder
whether the markets are ever going to recover and whether we should be
there at all.
Ironically, at these times, we
commonly fail to recognise that we are actually at the point of maximum
financial opportunity.
What are the consequences of
this emotional roller coaster?
Emotions turn rational investors
into irrational investors. As investors we need to remember that markets
move and our investments will always go in and out of favour.
Developed, diversified long-term
financial plans are placed in jeopardy when investors are confronted by
extraordinary events because we are guided by our emotions.
Chart 1: The Cycle of market
emotions

Source: Russell Investment Group
This is where the role of the
financial adviser is of utmost importance - your adviser will help you
separate your emotions from reality and endeavour to steer you on the path
of rational investing.
You can also help to avoid the
emotional roller coaster by being aware of the emotions you are likely to
experience.
The five most common behavioural
pitfalls are:
1. Overconfidence
When investors overrate their ability to select winning shares or
investment managers.
2. Loss aversion
Research indicates that a loss causes about twice as much pain as a gain
causes pleasure. During periods of market volatility investors experience
the sense of loss more acutely.
3. Chasing past performance
We see this time and time again, but unfortunately, individual investors
who are abandoning a well-diversified portfolio for bonds, or even cash,
may be jeopardising their future financial security.
4. Timing the market
Research shows that no one can accurately time the market.
5. Failure to rebalance
The risk/return characteristics of an investor's portfolio should be
independent of what's happening in the market and this means selling high
and buying low.
The temptation to fall into one of
these traps can be resisted by developing and committing to a well
defined, long-term investment policy. This is the best way to protect
yourself from your emotions.
Ask your financial planner about
the cycle of market emotions and the strategies you can put in place to
avoid the associated risks.
Remember, this is one part to
investing that is typically not considered but it can potentially have a
huge effect on where we put our hard earned dollars.
Source: Russell Investment Group
Covering all bases - Insurance through a
self-managed super fund can be highly tax-effective
Ongoing market turbulence over
the past 12 months has led to a rise in the number of self managed super
funds (SMSFs) seeking expert financial advice - but many members are still
not adequately covered when it comes to insurance.
Figures from the Australian
Taxation Office's compliance program show the total number of SMSFs has
trebled over the past decade to around $350 billion in retirement savings,
yet the total insurance cover within SMSFs is less than $300 million.
That's despite a recent Investment
Trends survey which showed 85 per cent of SMSFs were now seeking
professional advice.
Graeme Colley, chairman of the
SMSF Professionals' Association of Australia (SPAA), says many trustees
appear more focused on lowering costs and maximising portfolio returns
than ensuring their members are adequately protected.
"People who get into self managed
funds do it because they like to invest in direct shares, direct property
and to a degree some managed funds. But insurance doesn't seem to fit into
that investment decision," he said.
"A lot of that is to do with the
perceived cost of insurance and the average age of self managed fund
members, which is about 57. Insurance isn't a high priority for them.
From a tax-efficiency point of
view it's worrying because you've got people putting money into funds and
if they're able to pay their insurance premiums out of that rather than
out of their own pocket then the tax concessions are quite good."
While many people may acknowledge
the importance of insurance cover, many are still not aware of the various
incentives the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) now provides to hold them
via a SMSF.
The ATO allows a full tax
deduction for the cost of insurance held and owned by SMSFs over the life
of its members. At the moment, a wide range of personal insurances are
able to be held via SMSFs.
Brett Clark, the Chief Executive
of Retail Life at Tower Australia, said the inclusion of life, total and
permanent disability (TPD) and income protection for SMSF members provides
tax concessions that in most instances are not available for insurance
policies held outside of superannuation.
For example, assume the premium on
your policy is $1,000 per annum and your marginal tax rate is 31.5 per
cent, including Medicare.
If your insurance policy was held
outside your SMSF you would need to earn $1,460. Tax of $460 would also be
payable, leaving you with $1,000 to pay the insurance premium.
By holding the cover held inside a
SMSF you can arrange with your employer to salary sacrifice $1,000 of your
wages into super. Your employer will not deduct tax from this amount.
The fund would normally deduct 15
per cent tax from the contribution but the fund can claim a tax deduction
for the $1,000 insurance premium so no tax is deducted. The full $1,000 is
added to your superannuation account and then deducted to pay the
insurance premium.
This would provide a tax saving of
around $460 per annum, reducing the effective cost of the premium.
Recent changes in legislation have
also lifted restrictions on deductibility for certain income protection
policies, now making income protection attractive to hold via a SMSF.
Trustees can claim a tax deduction
for the full cost of the premium providing the policy only pays a
temporary disability benefit for the period that the member is unable to
perform the normal duties of their employment.
"The real message to anyone with
self managed super is to consider the tax efficiencies and look at whether
it's worth having insurance in their SMSF as opposed to insurance outside
of it. While there are benefits from holding life insurance inside a
superannuation vehicle, there are also good reasons why life cover should
be held outside superannuation vehicles. The importance of advice in
structuring these arrangements cannot be underestimated," Mr Clark said.
"For younger people in particular,
the big attraction is that they'll have the benefit of lower premiums as
well as tax benefits that stack up over time."
However, trustees of SMSFs, as
with any transaction or investment, need to be conscious of the various
Superannuation Industry Supervision Act and Income Tax Assessment Act
requirements when holding insurance through their SMSF.
That's why it's important to talk
to an experienced financial planner and to ensure that your SMSF Trust
Deed allows you to hold insurance through the SMSF structure.
Source: Tower Australia
Limited
Turning point for Aussie shares
There's still value to be had
from the Australian sharemarket, even in tough economic times.
The realisation that the credit
crisis has spread into the main economies of the world sent equity markets
into a tailspin in the second half of 2008. While belated government
interventions may avert an even worse financial catastrophe, markets
around the globe are now facing the sobering prospect of a severe
recession. And after 17 years of economic expansion, there is growing
concern that the Australian economy will suffer the same fate - a concern
that has caused chaos on our own sharemarket.
Whilst local investors had been
willing to shun financials from the early days of the credit crunch, there
had been a long-held belief that China would be able to sustain its strong
economic growth, in turn underpinning commodity prices, business
investment and the share prices of our mining companies. But China has
since shown that it too is not immune to the global slowdown. And while
China may be continuing to grow, it's no longer at a pace that can sustain
buoyant commodity prices.
As a result, the threat of a
global slowdown has resulted in a sharp sell-off in the resources sector,
which fell more than 44 per cent in the December half. The sell-off
certainly brought the performance of resources back to the pack after
significantly outperforming in the early stages of 2008 (see Chart 1
below).
Chart 1

Source: Zurich Australia
Limited
Competing forces
Since peaking in November 2007, the Australian sharemarket has suffered
one of the worst bear markets on record, falling around 42 per cent in
2008 alone. What's more, ongoing volatility with large share price
movements on a daily basis would suggest that it may still be premature to
call the bottom of the market. Nonetheless, valuations look compelling at
these levels, with many stocks and sectors trading at long-term lows.
The key issue for investors to
consider now is the additional earnings risk from the slowing domestic
economy, continued weakness in commodity prices and the longer-term
implications from the global financial meltdown. However, this needs to be
weighed against increasingly attractive valuations for equities. According
to Goldman Sachs JBWere research, the prospective price-earnings ratio
(PER) multiple for industrials is at its lowest level in 13 years.
Moreover, many equities are now trading at record discounts to their
discounted cash flow (DCF) valuations.
The key risk to both resource and
industrial earnings forecasts over the next 12 months continues to be a
worse-than-expected global slowdown, combined with a failure of the US and
other governments around the world to thaw capital markets.
Tough times ahead for resources
The decline in base metals prices
(e.g. copper, nickel and zinc, see Chart 2) has severely impacted the
prices of some 'pure-play' stocks, including Alumina, Kagara, and copper
junior Equinox. Against a backdrop of slowing growth, forecasts are still
being pared back on base metals for much of 2009. Whilst production costs
are falling, it is likely that lower prices will cause some cancellations
of new projects and expansions. Should China resume its demand growth in
the future, tighter supply may see commodity prices recover sharply, but
this is unlikely in the short term.
Meanwhile, falling spot prices for
bulk commodities (e.g. iron ore and coal) have tipped the scales in favour
of buyers at the expense of our miners in the lead-up to annual price
contract negotiations. The iron ore spot price has moved from a large
premium to a discount in a short space of time, hurting the share prices
of companies like Fortescue Metals and Mt Gibson Iron, as well as the
diversified majors BHP and Rio Tinto. After securing a record 85 per cent
price increase in the 2008-09 negotiations, expectations are for falling
prices with Chinese and Japanese steelmakers demanding a record 40 per
cent cut or more in iron ore prices. Coal stocks have been similarly
impacted.
Although resource stocks will
benefit from the declining Australian dollar, this will not be enough to
fully offset commodity price falls.
Chart 2

Source: Zurich Australia Limited
Industrials in 'fair' form
Surprisingly, industrial stocks
have seen a small up-tick in earnings forecasts, primarily resulting from
the sharp depreciation of the Australian dollar - a positive for companies
with offshore earnings exposure. Nevertheless, downside risks still exist
and may offset this currency influence.
The Federal Government's stimulus
package, coupled with the Reserve Bank's slashing of interest rates is
designed to provide a shot in the arm to the local economy. But whether
these measures succeed in stimulating consumer spending remains to be seen
given many Australians are still reeling from the widespread wealth
destruction from sharemarket falls and declining house prices. Add rising
unemployment to this economic mix and it doesn't augur well for retailers,
who tend to be particularly susceptible to a downturn in discretionary
spending.
Bargain basement financial
stocks
The banks are beginning to look
cheap, even after accounting for prevailing growth and bad debt risks.
Indeed, the demise of many non-bank lenders could certainly play to the
banks' advantage in the future, with the lower level of competition
allowing the bigger players to not only increase the size of their loan
books but also their margins, which have come under pressure in earlier
years.
The Commonwealth Bank has recently
acquired a 30 per cent stake in Aussie Home Loans, while Westpac was able
to swoop on RAMS, picking up the franchise quite cheaply after it became
an early victim of the credit crunch. The merger with St George was also
deemed to be a positive, giving the bank significant scale for the future.
More recently, all the majors have
moved to raise equity, bolstering their already high Tier 1 capital ratios
and have raised over US$23 billion on the international wholesale markets
(aided by the Federal Government's guarantee). Any future
re-intermediation due to reduced wholesale lending in credit markets will
also be a positive for the sector.
Has the market bottomed out?
While long-term valuations are
beginning to once again look attractive, it's highly likely that the
Australian sharemarket will continue to experience heightened levels of
volatility in the coming months. Despite some evidence that credit markets
are responding to broad-based global government initiatives, it will be
some time before confidence is fully restored. Furthermore, as the
prevailing economic outlook continues to deteriorate, further earnings
downgrades can be expected until they meet levels more attuned to a
recessionary environment.
Historically, the Australian
market turns the corner when earnings stabilise, which is unlikely until
the second half of 2009. This also suggests that Australian equities
represent excellent value on a three-year view.
Your financial planner can assist you in planning for your future. Call
your financial planner today.
Source: Zurich Australia
Limited
What is a redundancy payment, and how
much tax will I pay?
As we are becoming all too
aware, we're going to see an increasing number of redundancies this year
as the economic conditions require more and more companies to downsize. We
are already seeing increased redundancies in some industries.
In this article, we are going to
talk about the payments that your employer will make in the event that an
employee is made redundant.
You may be familiar with the term
'ETP', however just be aware that the meaning changed when the Simpler
Super rules were introduced in 2007.
In the old language, ETP stood for
Eligible Termination Payment and represented any lump sum payment from an
employer or a superannuation fund. Now the abbreviation stands for
Employer Termination Payment and refers to lump sum payments from an
employer only. An ETP is made as a consequence of termination of
employment, and excludes some payments.
Excluded payments are:
- Superannuation benefits;
- Unused annual or long service
leave;
- Pension or annuity payments;
- Foreign termination payments;
- Arm's length advance or loan;
- Deemed dividends;
- Compensation for personal
injury;
- Payments for restraint of
trade;
- Employee share scheme payments;
- Commutation of pensions; and
- Tax free amount of redundancy
or early retirement scheme payments.
The ETP must generally be made
within 12 months of the date of termination, and may also be paid as a
result of a person's death (a death benefit termination payment), however
we are focusing on life benefit termination payments and in particular
redundancy and golden handshakes.
When an employee receives a
redundancy payment, they will receive a lump sum from their employer
consisting of payments for any unused annual or long service leave that
has accrued plus an ex-gratia amount that will often be calculated in
accordance with a formula based on their years of service.
To calculate the amount that is
treated as an ETP for tax purposes, the payer (the employer) will ignore
the leave payments (these have their own tax treatment) and any of the
above excluded payments, and calculate the tax free amount known as the
Genuine Redundancy Payment.
Genuine redundancy payment (tax
free) = $7,350 + ($3,676 x completed years of service)
What is left over is the ETP. If
the employee joined the company before 1 July 1983, the ETP gets split
into a tax free and a taxable component, with the pre 1983 component being
the tax free amount:
Tax Free component = ETP x Days of
service prior to 1 July 1983/total service days
Taxable component = ETP component
- tax free component.
The taxable component is taxed as shown in the table below.
|
Age |
Below ETP cap ($145,000 for
08/09) |
Above ETP cap ($145,000 for
08/09) |
| Above
preservation age (55+) |
Max tax 16.5% |
Top marginal rate |
| Below
preservation age (<55) |
Max tax 31.5% |
Top marginal rate |
Here are some examples of how this
works:
Example 1
Tony is 56 and has been working
for a life insurance company since 24 May 1979. On 28 October 2008 he was
made redundant. The payment, excluding his unused leave payments, totalled
$300,000. These figures are shown in the table below.
|
Example 1 |
| Genuine
Redundancy amount |
$7,350 + ($3,676
x 29) |
$113,954 |
| ETP |
$300,000 -
$113,954 |
$186,046 |
| Tax free
component of ETP |
$186,046 x
(1499/10,751)* |
$25,940 |
| Taxable component |
$186,046 -
$25,940 |
$160,106 |
| The first
$145,000 |
Taxed at 16.5% |
$23,925 |
| The rest |
($160,106 -
$145,000) x 46.5% |
$7,024 |
| Total tax on
$300,000 |
|
$30,949 |
| Net payment |
|
$269,051 |
*Days of service prior to 1 July
1983/Total service days
Example 2
Andy is 41 and has been working
for a fund manager since 20 November 2006. He was made redundant on 28
October 2008 and also received a payment, excluding his unused leave
payments, of $300,000.
|
Example 2 |
| Genuine
redundancy amount |
$7,350 + ($3,696
x 1) |
$11,046 |
| ETP (no pre 83
service) |
$300,000-$11,046 |
$288,954 |
| The first
$145,000 |
Taxed at 31.5% |
$45,675 |
| The rest |
($288,954 -
$145,000) x 46.5% |
$66,938 |
| Total tax on
$300,000 |
|
$112,613 |
| Net payment |
|
$187,387 |
Andy, being younger and with much
less service, pays a lot more tax than Tony on the I same gross payment.
Unfortunately, this payment cannot be rolled over to superannuation, so
there isn't anything either one can do to reduce or manage this tax unless
they fall under 1*6 transitional arrangements.
Transitional arrangements (to
30 June 2012)
Transitional arrangements apply to
payments made between 1 July 2007 and 30 June 2012 if the employee was
entitled, as at 9 May 2006, to such a payment specified under:
- a written contract;
- an Australian or foreign law
(or an instrument under such a law); or
- a workplace agreement under the
Workplace Relations Act 1996.
These documents must do this by
referring to the amount of the payment or a method or formula to work it
out.
Transitional termination payments
may be rolled over (in full or part) to a superannuation
fund or a superannuation annuity.
If you are receiving a redundancy
and think you might fall under a transitional arrangement, it is very
important to speak to your financial planner as there are many options
available to you.
Source: Challenger
Estate planning essentials
Effective estate planning
provides you with the peace of mind that the right asset will go to the
right person at the right time when you're no longer around.
Do you have an up-to-date Will? Do
you have a power of attorney? If you've answered yes to both these
questions, then you're one step ahead of many Australians, 40 per cent of
whom don't have a valid Will. But an effective estate plan goes beyond
having a current and valid Will. It considers any tax and/or social
security implications for beneficiaries, as well as ownership structures
and other Issues. That's where an experienced financial planner can add
significant value.
Exclusion issues with Wills
If you are planning to leave an
'eligible person' out of your Will, it's important to seek specialist
legal advice about the issues that could arise and their potential impact
on your beneficiaries. Each state and territory has legislation that
ensures certain individuals receive an entitlement to a deceased estate.
This group of eligible individuals includes a spouse, children and certain
financial dependants. If inadequate provision is made from an estate for
an eligible person, there is the possibility of the estate being
contested. The courts then decide how to divide up the estate to ensure
all eligible beneficiaries are adequately provided for.
More estate planning options
In addition to the Will, different
ownership and investment structures may be used to complement your estate
planning objectives. Some of the ways assets can be structured to bypass
the estate include owning property as joint tenants, binding nominations
for super, insurance policies owned by a beneficiary, inter vivos trusts
and testamentary trusts.
Testamentary trusts provide the
following benefits:
- capital retention within the
structure for a specified period (e.g. until a beneficiary turns a
certain age)
- catering for beneficiaries with
special needs (e.g. minors, spendthrifts, gamblers etc.)
- protecting assets in the event
of a beneficiary's marriage breakdown or bankruptcy.
Good record keeping
Capital gains tax (CGT) records
should be kept for all investments to allow an accurate tax calculation.
Generally, CGT is not payable when an owner dies and the asset is directed
to the beneficiary. However, when the beneficiary sells the asset, a CGT
event is triggered. In addition to records documenting purchase price and
costs, thorough records should be kept capturing transactions such as
dividend/fund income reinvestments, bonus share issues and company
takeovers and mergers. Without appropriate records, a beneficiary will
have considerable difficulty calculating the correct tax payable.
Super tax considerations
Superannuation law specifies who
can be paid a death benefit from a super fund. Super dependants can
include a spouse, child, financial dependant or someone in an
interdependent relationship with the member. Alternatively, the death
benefit can be paid to the deceased member's estate. Consideration should
be given to directing superannuation to death benefits dependants, who
will receive the funds tax free, and non-super assets should ideally be
directed to other beneficiaries.
Estate planning is a critical
component of the financial planning process. If you do not have a Will and
power of attorney, or your documents are out of date, or a trigger event
as noted has occurred, it is wise to consult your financial planner who
will review your circumstances or refer you to a professional who can
identify any gaps in your estate plan.
Source: Zurich Australia
Limited
Disclaimer:
The information contained in this document is based on information
believed
to be accurate and
reliable at the time of publication. Any illustrations
of past performance do not imply similar performance in the future.
To the extent
permissible by law, neither we nor any of our related entities, employees,
or directors gives any representation or warranty as to the reliability,
accuracy or completeness of the information; or accepts any responsibility
for any person acting, or refraining from acting, on the basis of
information contained in this newsletter.
This
information is of a general nature only. It is not intended as personal
advice or as an investment recommendation, and does not take into account
the particular investment objectives, financial situation and needs of a
particular investor. Before making an investment decision you should read
the product disclosure statement of any financial product referred to in
this newsletter and speak with your financial planner to assess whether
the advice is appropriate to your particular investment objectives,
financial situation and needs.
Austbrokers Phillips Pty Ltd
T: (03) 8586 9333 F: (03) 8586 9394
E: info@austbrokersphillips.com.au
Level 2,424 Warrigal Road,
Moorabbin VIC 3189
www.austbrokersphlllips.com.au |